Thursday, 19 March 2015

Is the IC-7100 a good rig?

I have an IC-7100. All of those 45 aurora contacts made on 17 March were made using it.

I am asked would I recommend it. Well, yes, if you know what you are letting yourself in for.

Plus features are many - small size of the control unit, nifty touch screen controls, reasonable price, RF DSP, 4m for Europe, good frequency stability for data modes, USB lead to PC allowing direct audio in/out for data, DStar, coverage up to 70cms, ....

The snags I have experienced and my solutions are - low output powers on SSB (needs separate microphone with compressor), "clicking noise" (not a big thing, I am ignoring it), RF getting back into the control cable (use a short screened ethernet cable CAT6 or higher), deep cut on ALC a problem with QRN (electric fence problem in my case, turn ALC off).

OK, there are some problems, which are capable of being fixed. I complained to Icom about the clicking noise and they said they were looking into it and that they would reply with a solution soon. They did not reply. Also, the local dealer said the same thing and never replied. We are on our own with this one, but it is better just ignored.

For SSB and FM I use an Adonis 508 microphone set to low compression. That allows me to get the power up to the stated outputs, more or less. When I tried to raise this issue on the various sites, I got lectures about the difference between peak and mean power on SSB. Look, I know about that. Yes, I do have a peak reading power meter. There is just no way my 7100 can run the stated peak power on SSB using the internal compression and the supplied mic. But with an external amplified mic and the internal compression turned off I can get good results. And I DO  KNOW ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PEAK AND AVERAGE POWER.

EDIT - there is a mod for this which I have not tried, but I know some people who have. There are in fact two mods here, however I believe that only one of them should be done (the soft one looks best to me) - see here http://gm4fvm.blogspot.co.uk/2016/02/ic-7100-low-ssb-output-surgical-solution.html

On data modes it is a triumph. It runs full stated power for ages and does not complain - like a meteor scatter contact with Italy lasting 3 hours! I have used it on FSK441, WSPR, JT65, JT9 PSK, JT6 ... all fine. No problem there at all, which makes the SSB performance a bit disappointing. But I fitted an external mic and I am in business on SSB too.

I don't use DStar so I cannot comment on that. Receiver wise it is OK, but I mostly use 12m and 10m on HF. I would guess it is OK on 80m and top band, but at this price it might not be brilliant in adverse conditions. I bought an LDG IT-100 ATU which is great but I have not used it much. My IC-7100 runs fine on 2m and 70cms.

It might be helping that my IC-7100 generally runs into linear amplifiers, which may cover up the low SSB power issue - on 6m an RM VLA150, on 4m a TE Systems 0610G and on 2m a Microset SR200. With that set-up - it blasts along.

So, I am happy enough and I would not want to put anyone off. But it should be better on SSB transmit. If the touch screen works first time it seems to be fine, in the shack anyway. Not sure how it would work portable or mobile where it would get strong light hitting it. The control unit stays steady if you extend the stabilising feet behind it.

OK, I am peeved to buy a whizzo rig with an internal DSP compressor, and then turn the internal system off and have to use a 1970s technology outboard mic. But after 18 months I have got over that one. It is OK. I wouldn't put anyone off. And for Europeans (or Africans or Asians in some places!) looking for a 4m/ 70MHz rig, it is a reasonable choice.

Finally, a recent firmware upgrade to the DSP and audio might have had the effect of helping the ALC dip issue. It seems better, but it has not gone away. I would suggest that you live somewhere away from electric fences.

Jim
GM4FVM

7 comments:

  1. Hi Jim, Same issues on SSB here. Rig been back to Icom UK and yes, I've had the lectures;-) The reality is, the peak output is VERY low and no amount of tweaking the compression etc fixes the problem. My real issue is that the peak is SO low that, if I adjust the drive to my SSPA for SSB the, if I switch to CW I blow the hell out of it! Great bells and whisltes but on SSB it's a dog:-( 73 Peter G8BCG

    ReplyDelete
  2. Peter
    Thanks. I hadn't really thought about that aspect of it until you posted this reply. You are quite right. The way you describe it makes it clear that I need to be careful.
    With my normal settings into my linear on 4m, I routinely set the drive to 33% to acheive 100W SSB peak. Even that is not full output. On FM the maximum output from the linear comes at just 13% drive.
    I need to watch out or I will blow up the linear on the odd occasion when I swtich to FM.
    Quite a few people have written to me. I will have to write another posting about the 7100.
    I really like it, but there is this one issue which troubles so many people ...
    73
    Jim

    ReplyDelete
  3. There is a mod for this, unlucky Icom is unwilling to correct their huge flaw in the design.. did they even put a ham operator to test it before it was shipped? I am convinced they did not.

    ReplyDelete
  4. There is a mod for this, unlucky Icom is unwilling to correct their huge flaw in the design.. did they even put a ham operator to test it before it was shipped? I am convinced they did not.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks Mads. After I read your note I updated both this post and the one on the mod - I put a link between them. You are right, Icom should have known this, and they were told as soon as the rig went on sale. I do not know if later rigs are better. What really annoys me is that a certain "reviewer" told me to leave his review site when I reported this issue right at the start. Be careful everyone. Some people who "review" rigs are not open to hearing the truth.
    Thanks.
    Jim

    ReplyDelete
  6. Low SSB level here too on output....but digi modes it is great.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jan.
      Seems to be a common problem.
      I wonder if anybody on this blog has tried the physical modifications
      http://gm4fvm.blogspot.co.uk/2016/02/ic-7100-low-ssb-output-surgical-solution.html
      It would be interesting to hear from anyone who has tried either of these.
      Jim

      Delete